Wish You Were Her
Elle McNicoll
Wednesday Books
Published August 26, 2025
Amazon | Bookshop | Goodreads
About Wish You Were Her
Book Lovers meets Notting Hill with a slice of You’ve Got Mail in Wish You Were Her, the brand new rivals-to-lovers romance from bestselling, award-winning Elle McNicoll.
18-year-old Allegra Brooks has skyrocketed to fame after starring in a hit television show, and she’s the overnight success that everyone’s talking about. They just don’t know she’s autistic. Now, all she wants is a normal teenage summer.
Her destination for escape is the remote Lake Pristine and its annual Book Festival, organized by the dedicated but unfriendly senior bookseller, Jonah Thorne.
In small towns like Lake Pristine, misunderstandings abound, and before long the two are drawn into high-profile hostility that’s a far cry from the drama-free holiday Allegra was craving. Thank goodness for her saving the increasingly personal emails she’s been sharing with a charming and anonymous bookseller who is definitely not Jonah Thorne . . .
An unforgettable romcom about finding the one person who makes you feel yourself when the whole world is watching.
My Review
I thought the You’ve Got Mail vibes were very strong with this story– and I love that! There’s a scene in which one character waits for another at a coffee shop with a book and a rose, which will leave You’ve Got Mail fans immediately thinking of a similar scene from the movie.
Both the main characters in Wish You Were Her are autistic (they discuss this as their preferred way to be labeled in the book). I can’t think of another romance novel I’ve read where that’s true, so I was really excited to see it here. They share some similar experiences and differences, which helps remind readers that this diagnosis doesn’t appear the same way in every person.
Ally’s questions about whether or not to announce her diagnosis publicly made a lot of sense, too. I like that the story made space for her to think about that question in multiple different ways.
The bulk of the story takes place in a small town preparing for a book festival, which was lots of fun. Ally meets some new friends, and she uses her fame to disrupt some of the toxic social hierarchy among the teens she spends time with. It was another nice note in the story.
Ally and Jonah’s relationship is a bit rocky. I didn’t always expect some of their reactions to one another, but it still felt authentic. Ultimately, I had a great time reading this sweet story and loved the references to You’ve Got Mail. I love that one of the characters mentions the Jimmy Stewart original, The Shop Around the Corner.
Conclusion
If you’re looking for a bookish romance with characters who start out on the wrong foot, definitely grab this one. Bonus if you’re looking for a book with neurodivergent main characters and/or autistic representation.
Content Notes
Recommended for Ages 16 up.
Profanity/Crude Language Content
Strong profanity used fairly infrequently.
Romance/Sexual Content
Kissing. Making out. A couple kiss while in their underwear. Brief references to sex. In one scene, a character kisses someone without consent. References to people making inappropriate sexual comments to someone.
Spiritual Content
None.
Violent Content
One character.
Drug Content
One teen drinks alcohol trying to forget worries.
Note: This post contains affiliate links, which do not cost you anything to use but help support this blog. I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.