The Lost Girl of Astor Street
Published February 7, 2017
Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Goodreads
Eighteen-year-old Piper Sail’s best friend Lydia goes missing from a neighborhood street in 1924 Chicago. Piper vows to find her friend, even if she has to take up the investigation herself. As Piper begins to hunt for Lydia, she soon learns everyone in her neighborhood hides a secret, even her father and the handsome detective who’s working the case. Piper realizes finding the truth may cost her newfound love, her respect for her family, and possibly, her own life.
I loved this book! I was hooked from the first page. Immediately we meet interesting (and funny!) characters and see complex relationships. There were a few elements of the mystery that I kind of saw coming, and I worried that would make the ending too obvious. It did not. The Lost Girl of Astor Street had plenty of twists and turns to keep me guessing at the real story behind Lydia’s disappearance and the odd behavior of some of the other characters.
The plot elements tied together well enough to be believable but also not feel too convenient—which I think is a delicate balance in a mystery. Piper kept busy with a lot of sub-plots, all interesting stuff that ultimately provided other pieces in the grander puzzle of the story.
One really random thing I enjoyed a lot was all the hats. It seemed like whenever anyone went anywhere, there were great hats involved. I loved that!
I definitely recommend this book. I loved the characters, found the mystery elements well-paced, and seriously enjoyed the adventure in 1920s Chicago. This one is a must-read for mystery and historical lovers.
Piper learns a little bit about the Irish and Italian mafia. She dates an Italian detective, and some friends/family members disapprove of the relationship. Piper’s friend Lydia has seizures.
Profanity/Crude Language Content
A few brief male-female kisses. Piper hears a story about a girl her age rescued from a human trafficking ring. She visits some places that prostitutes frequent as part of her search for Lydia.
At one point, Piper feels discouraged, feeling like she’ll never find Lydia. She says the only thing left to do is cry out to God, if you believe He’s there.
A couple of scenes are set in a church—funeral and wedding.
A young woman is shot. A captor interrogates a young woman, hitting her and shoving her underwater when the girl refuses to answer questions.
Piper’s family enjoys wine with dinner, despite Prohibition laws. (Piper herself doesn’t drink.) Piper’s brother comes home drunk and says some unkind things to her.
What is the secret??
What is the big secret she finds out
There are lots of secrets in the story that come out as you read. I don’t want to give too much away! Each secret Piper uncovers challenges her relationship with its keeper. You’ll have to read the book for more specifics. 🙂
This sounds amazing – exactly the sort of book I fancy reading at the moment! I might have to go check it out on goodreads 😀
I hope you check it out and enjoy it! 🙂
Great review! 🙂 I usually enjoy historical mysteries, so this sounds like my cup of tea. I fully intend to check it out.
It’s SOOOOO good! I hope you love it!
Love this author, so I was hopeful you would rave about her book. I am so glad you could! Thank you for another great review.
Me too!! Thanks, Colleen. Your support means a lot. 🙂